I recently convinced a six pack of friends to join me in celebrating over a dozen “delicious” brews from around the country. By the time I had narrowed the choices for the night, we had a total of 16 craft brews “on tap” ranging from wheat beer to porter and lots of stinky, hoppy brews in between.
Some of these beers were picked up along the roadways of Pennsylvania, Maryland and Delaware during my recent beer trip.
In devising a system that I thought would work well, I offered up the sweeter or less bitter beers first and moved up the hoppy bitterness scale before taking a step back with a delicious mellow porter. I think this order was important with the huge hops content in the second two thirds of the samples. Let’s face it, some of the tasters (me included) may have thought “hops” was what I exhibited playing high school back in the day.
The 16 beers that we sampled, from 8 different states, in order, were:
- Allagash White Ale (ME)
- Southampton Publick House Double White Ale (NY)
- Harpoon Catamount Maple Wheat (MA)
- Lagunitas Little Sumpin Sumpin’ Ale (CA)
- Heavy Seas Small Craft Advisory Uber Pils (MD)
- Founders Brewing Dirty Bastard Scotch Ale (MI)
- Flying Dog Raging Bitch Belgian Style IPA (MD)
- Founders Brewing Centennial IPA (MI)
- New England Brewing Sea Hag IPA (CT)
- Victory Brewing Hop Devil Ale (PA)
- Bell’s Brewery Two Hearted Ale (MI)
- Founders Brewing Red’s Rye PA (MI)
- Troegs HopBack Amber Ale (PA)
- Bear Republic Red Rocket Ale (CA)
- Troegs Nugget Nectar Imperial Amber Ale (PA)
- Founders Brewing Porter (MI)

The tasters for the night have had their names partially changed to protect them from getting a hard time from hops lovers throughout the greater Woburn region. The tasters were:
- Buckbites (moderator and taster)
- P Dots
- S Dots
- S Cal
- D Cal
- T Fic
- E Fic
In their most sober state, E Fic and D Cal are shown gearing up for the first tastes of the evening.

Individuals were provided some information that was culled from the Internet, paired with scoring sheets I prepared. Individual packets included:
- The Art of Tasting
- Descriptions of the Varieties of Beer to be Tasted
- Scoring sheets, which provided names of beer and free form text areas (no numerical ratings were used for this group).
Some, like S Cal, took time out of the excitement to study up on the pre-tasting information.

Beer types to be tasted were:
- Witbier (Wheat Beer)
- American Pale Ale
- American Double / Imperial Pilsner
- Scotch Ale
- Belgian Style IPA
- American IPA
- Rye Beer
- American Amber / Red Ale
- American Porter
Information on the types of beer was researched through Beer Advocate.
The chef for the night (S Dots), doubling as beer taster #3 (but chef #1), provided lots of tasty delights, with highlights being buffalo chicken dip with celery and nacho chips, roasted red potatoes with a delicious horseradish chive sour cream sauce, crab cakes with lemon dill sauce and these wonderful beef crostini with sage whipped cream. All of these were top notch and I am not word-worthy enough to describe how delish they were! Bravo chef!



Below are the tasting note summaries. I have also included a subjective ranking of 1 through 5 beers – 5 being the best rating and 1 being the worst rating.
Beer #1 – Allagash White Ale -


Spicy
Lemon
Could use lemon
Not a fan of aftertaste
Fizzy
Unsure
Modest aroma
Spicy
Light & Refreshing
Dark Yellow Color
Cloudy
Summery
Beer #2 – Southampton Double White



Fruity
Not liking aftertaste
Bad smell
Light
Very clear
Light head
Slightly more bitter than Allagash
Lots of bubbles
Stinky
Fizzy
Beer #3 – Harpoon Catamount Maple Wheat





Pleasing scent
Lightish
Sweet smell
Bananas
Caramel
Alcohol-y
Light, but nice body
Good color
Don’t like it
Bitter
Dig this!
Could drink a whole one
Beer #4 – Lagunitas Little Sumpin’ Sumpin Ale




Lemony
Citrus
Berry
Tart
Lousy
Berryish
Fruity
Bitter
Dry
Cherry
Hops
Didn’t like finish
Beer #5 – Heavy Seas Small Craft Advisory – Uber Pils





Fizzy
Bitter
Clovey
Smells like beer
Good, bitter though
Don’t like after taste
Beer #6 – Founders Dirty Bastard Scotch Ale


Thick
Syrup-y
Can’t drink a whole one
G-nasty
Coffee
Strong
Malty
Peppery
Smoky
Beer #7 – Flying Dog Raging Bitch Belgian Style IPA




Fruity Aroma
I comb my tongue with my teeth
Tastes like detergent
Like an IPA with a white ale finish
Hoppy
Fruity
Like It!
Beer #8 – Founders Brewing Centennial IPA



Smells fruity
Strong
Spicy
Alcohol taste
IPA Hoppy
Lemon/citrus
Fruity
Beer #9 – New England Brewing Sea Hag IPA




I Like the Lady!
Ouch!
Fruity
Less hoppy IPA
No smell
Unlike other IPA’s
Beer #10 – Victory Brewing Hop Devil Ale






Yummy
Hops
Nice label
Like it, actually
Heavy flavor
Very good
Good
Fruity
Bisquit-like
Beer #11 – Bell’s Brewery Two Hearted Ale




Lemon
Very good
Didn’t like that one
Like a meadow
Flowery
Fruity
Beer #12 – Founders Brewing Red’s Rye PA


Hops
Grapefruit
Citrusy
No different than an IPA
Hoppy
Beer #13 – Tröegs HopBack Amber Ale






Very Good ***
Yummy
Good Color
Tasty
My favorite
Beer #14 – Bear Republic Red Rocket Ale





Not crazy about finish
I like this one a lot
Tasty
I like
More Hops
Complex
Beer #15 – Tröegs Nugget Nectar



Powerful aroma
Nasty
Like Feet
Lighter than the sister
Fizzy
Hops a lot
Smells Nasty!
And just a note, I had trouble with ‘da hops a couple months back, but I am now endorsing the stinky feet of the Nugget Nectar!!

Beer #16 – Founders Brewing Porter





Coffee
Chocolate Smell
Smokey
Syrup Appearance, but not as heavy tasting
Complex
Thinner than expected
Would try again
The crowd had their ups and downs, favorites and ones for which they were not wanting a second sip.
In general, the favorites of the night in no particular order were:
- Troegs HopBack Amber Ale
- Founders Porter
- Harpoon Catamount Maple Wheat
- Heavy Seas Small Craft Advisory Uber Pils
- Bear Republic Red Rocket
- Victory Beer Hop Devil
Honorable mentions: Which usually meant infatuation with the name and or label:
- Founders Dirty Bastard Scotch Ale
- Raging Bitch Belgian Style IPA

Pleasant surprise:
- New England Brewery Sea Hag IPA — surprise at decent flavored IPA in a can. This was the only beer that came in a can.
The food was great — the beer was interesting and the company was long overdue —
Until the next time — Cheers!